We are Community

First, we are a family that lives in Clintonville with our children, and we love helping our community prosper. That spills over to our extended family—our wonderful team members—who are contributing to local communities in so many great ways.

We are Quality

We make delicious dough and sauce daily, use the freshest ingredients, and cook a great variety of top quality foods for our foodies to enjoy.

Your complete satisfaction guaranteed or your money back!

We are Friendly

People say they enjoy our cheerful welcomes and how we greet them by name.  That makes us happy because we really work at delivering great customer service to each and every person.

Our StoryOur Core ValuesCommunity InvolvementOur Managers

Family Owned  and Operated Sub & Pizza Shop Since 2002

I started Pizza Primo in 2002 with the intent of bringing great pizza to the community. I grew up in Clintonville, attended Bishop Watterson High School and Ohio State, and have been an avid Buckeye fan for as long as I can remember. Serving the local community is just in my blood.

Before opening my own stores, I worked for another small chain of pizzerias and learned a great deal about food service.

In the past decade, we have grown to two stores that feature a menu with many tasty items in addition to pizza, and great catering services. By keeping our customers happy, we hope to open a third local shop soon.

Family-owned and family-operated, Pizza Primo is focused on pleasing every guest with delicious food and friendly service. We are committed to offering the highest quality ingredients, making our dough fresh daily in-house, keeping our signature sauce a secret, and working hard to create loyal customers and team members, while having fun in the process.

With regards,
Eric Rummel

At Pizza Primo, we believe in . . .

  • Quality
  • Service
  • Integrity
  • Responsibility
  • Fun
  • Growth

Pizza Primo Supports the Communities it Serves

The Pizza Primo team is committed to the growth of the communities in which we do business. It is our mission to provide as much support as possible to local schools, non-profit groups, and community organizations. We often participate as individuals or groups in community events and fundraisers . . . because kindness makes a difference!

David Bennett – General Manager

True to the family nature of the business, David Bennett is Eric’s nephew. He was raised in Worthington and graduated with the Thomas Worthington Class of 2003, after which he attended Ohio University. He has been in the pizza industry for over 10 years.

David has worked for many local businesses, caddied for Brookside Country Club, and was a cashier for Jubilee foods, a local grocery store. He also worked for IGS energy as a call center supervisor for six years, then worked in the mortgage industry for J P Morgan Chase for two years.

In his off time, he enjoys golfing with friends and watching the Buckeyes, Browns, and Indians. He is single with no kids.

Eric Rummel – CEO and Founder

Eric Rummel is CEO and founder of Pizza Primo, headquartered in Columbus, Ohio. A lifelong entrepreneur, Eric loves the restaurant industry and became hooked for life on the pizza business when, in 1993, he started as a delivery driver in what is now Pizza Primo’s Worthington location. Eric worked his way to manager of the Worthington location and then founded Pizza Primo in 2002.

Eric was born and raised in Clintonville, attended Bishop Watterson High School and The Ohio State University. An avid fan of the Bishop Watterson Eagles and Ohio State Buckeyes, Eric loves to cater team events at his special school pricing.

Eric lives in Clintonville with his wife, Kelsey, their daughter, Kenley, and son, Lachlan. He is an active and proud supporter of his local community.


When ordering, please order from the location where you want to pick up your order or from where you want it delivered.

Order Online

By Phone:


895 High Street
Worthington, OH 43085
Located across from CVS in Worthington Center


3027 Indianola Avenue
Clintonville, OH 43202
Located half block south of Studio 35 Theatre


Sunday 3 to 11 pm
Monday-Thursday 10:30 am to 11 pm
Friday 10:30 am to Midnight
Saturday 3 pm to Midnight

Sunday-Thursday 3 pm to 11 pm
Friday-Saturday 3 pm to Midnight


Pizza Primo offers two convenient locations to serve you better. Use the map below for directions or visit our locations page.

Delivery Area

Pizza Promo offers free delivery in a wide area around our locations. To find out if we deliver to your location, visit our delivery area page.

Specials & Rewards

Check out our specials. Earn points. Get food.
Learn More →

Tell Others